“I don’t dance in the place, but I am the place.” – Min Tanaka¹
Ma is a Japanese term that means “in the gaps and intervals of time, space and being.” In other words, liminality which is also connected to paradox. Ma is used in endless ways.² As artists, it’s recommended to think in terms of space or in-between.
The subbody and ma as a whole appear to be in a deep symbiotic relationship. If the subbody is associated with a rhizomic multi-dimensional world, then ma is its in-between-space-and-time container, ground, and/or vehicle. Rhizome Lee calls ma resonance itself.11
Creating space, emptying, and quieting are also regarded as the initial conditions needed for creation in butoh and anything in general.
Miki Seifert, while admitting that any definition would only be partial, has invented the term butoh space to be “the lived experience where the boundaries between mind/body, self/others and self/environment are erased and from which it is possible to create authentic movement, where the quotidian experience of self, time and space is altered.”16
Space — Hijikata’s space qualia butoh-fu.
“Physical appearance, activities, and meanings are the raw material of the identity of places.” – Ralph Edwards³
Any place, set, or setting is fair game in Butoh, whether inside a box, or street. The space can even be imaginary and/or psychological (e.g. bad ma ≈ bad vibes). Within the place, we have space. As Peter Brooks notes, “I can take any empty space and call it a bare stage. A man walks across this empty space whilst someone else is watching him, an this is all that is needed for an act of theatre to be engaged.”5 See section Audience & Show for more on the performance space.
Not only is the term ma used for a walled room, but also for the space between the walls.7
Deleuze and Guattari’s use of haecceity encompasses a segment of experience where the place/set/setting is not separate from the self: “Climate, wind, season, hour are not of another nature than the things, animals , or people that populate them, [but] follow them, sleep and awaken within them. This should be read without a pause: the-animal-stalks-at-five-o’clock. The becoming-evening, becoming-night of an animal, blood nuptials. Five o’clock is this animal! This animal is this place!”8
According to Contemporary Metaphor Theory, place is a CONTAINER image schema20 because we use inside/outside language when speaking of it such as: “We are in New York. “We are in love.” Image schemas to Lakoff and Johnson are “recurrent patterns in perceptual-motor experience that derive from our bodily interaction with the physical world.”20 To Boroditsky, they are a prelinguistic groundwork for creation of conceptual metaphor mappings.”21
Exercise 1: Child Vision
Look around the entire space as if for the first time. Have child vision. Do not judge or compare, only notice.
Exercise 2: Space Infiltration
Exercise 3: Space Crescendo/Decrescendo
From one space to the other, the participant begins with the qualia limitless space (refer to exercise 2 above), but then as one gradually goes to the other end of the space, the space gets more contracted until it becomes the most cramped.
“Every moment is a gift.” – David Steindl-Rast19
According to Sri Sri Ravi Shankar, bhakti in Sanskrit means that commonality between one and the infinite space.9 Performance of this type draws a full communion with space, and to Shankar is connected to Divine Love itself. This is full life resonance. This is taking 100% presence to life itself.
Ma as Transition
If ma is viewed as the in-between/liminal, transition is deeply related to it because transition is itself in-between two things. As butoh dancers, we must get into the habit of being in endless transition and developing transitions even where one would not think to find one, e.g. audience member → performing bubbles qualia → the face that begins tilling the field. What is between the qualia of an audience member and that of bubbles? How long can we stretch this transition?
Transition can be related to Filler & Scribble, a rich idling in performance.
“If you move yourself, people can’t see the space around you.” – Nagaoka Seisaku18
As a whole, space can also be thought of as: (1) yang (positive); (2) yin (negative); (3) yin-yang (neutral/beyond).
Negative space, on the other hand, is associated with someone or something outside of oneself. When utilizing negative space, the performer is often being moved by someone or something. There is little or no ego involved and there is a general openness or innocence. This being moved by space itself is also the main concept behind Akaji Maro’s Chūtai (Space-Body).
Neutral space is associated with both positive and negative or beyond. In neutral space, the performer touches the negative space with positive space. Neutral space may also be associated with the origin, the source, death, or the unborn. To Rhizome Lee, this can be related to a transparent Riken, watching oneself from the outside during performance (and maintaining 50% inside and 50% outside).12
Exercise: Single String Puppet
To shift focus from utilizing positive space to utilizing negative space, attach an imaginary string to any part of your body and move as if it were pulling you. We will be working with the concept of the string further in the text.
There are high, middle and low levels of space. Maximum high level takes place physically on the balls of the feet or visually in the sky. Maximum low level takes place physically as a body flat on the ground or visually down to the core of the earth.
Exercise: Laser Chaser
Like a cat who chases a laser, chase the laser at ground level, but also at the varying levels against the wall.
The performer can resonate within any space, whether it is a big gymnasium or a small suit case, e.g. Hijikata’s boxed body from his Quiet House butoh-fu.4 The participant can also space-bend a fixed space. See the following exercise.
Exercise: Space Stretching
Take 5 seconds to get from one side of a space to another. Then go back toward the other side but only half way for another 5 seconds. Then go back with yet another half for 5 more seconds. Continue this until the space is stretched so thin, you appear to be nearly frozen. Try to keep the time it gets from getting from one space to the other uniformly. After you have become proficient in this, then you can stylize the timings like with crescendos, etc.
Direction & Pathway
To Contemporary Metaphor Theory, these go back to the womb and are described as the UP-DOWN, FRONT-BACK image schema.20 Image schemas to Lakoff and Johnson are “recurrent patterns in perceptual-motor experience that derive from our bodily interaction with the physical world.”21
Exercise: Breath Across Space aka Lunging
The participant goes across the space on inspiration and backwards upon expiration. Work with different speeds connected to breath. You can also do the same along the walls in the room, returning back to where you began.
To get an idea of relationship, think of prepositions. Here is a list: aboard, about, above, across, after, against, along, amid, among, anti, around, as,at, before, behind, below, beneath, beside, between, beyond, by, down, from, in, inside, into, near, of, off, on, onto, opposite, outside, over, past, round, through, to, toward, under, up, upon, with, within, without.
Relationship is one form in which ma is used. Günter Nitschke expresses the idea: “Even in a simple one-dimensional use, the character ma exhibits its peculiar ambivalence, signifying both ‘distance’ or ‘interstice’ and ‘relatedness’ or ‘polarity.’5
Exercise: Prop Relationship
Plug in the prepositions with any prop, e.g. chair or scarf.
Merging with the Space
The following is a space resonance exercise documented by P. Liao during a Hokutobo Butoh Dance Company workshop in Taiwan, 1996. This concept is also the bases of Akaji Maro’s Chūtai (Space-Body).
Stand in a corner of a space. Observe and feel the space. Try to move the body. Find the gesture/posture that is felt to best correspond to the space. In other words the bodily gesture/posture should best represent the sensations given by the space, such as its length, width, and depth, whether it is spacious or crowded, bright or dark, warm or cold, the air flow if any, the texture of the wall…
Stand further away from the corner. Repeat the previous sequence until a new gesture/posture has been found. Change the standing locus for a third time. Repeat the same sequence.
Compare the bodily gestures/postures obtained in the three loci. Examine and feel how they link to the whole space and are influenced by the change of loci. Develop a sequence of bodily movement, moving from the first locus, through the second, to the third locus.The bodily gesture/posture in each locus should keep corresponding to the space, and the transition from one bodily gesture/posture to another should also keep corresponding to the space.6
“Nothing can be stated about the ‘void.’ It is impossible even to think about it. Nevertheless, enlightened ones […] have created many devices with which they have tried to lure their disciples into a state of being in which the above phrase does make sense.” – Gunther Nitschke5
This is the archetypal hostile space/ma. It is often the censored block itself to past hardships or traumas. In the subbody or shadowbody, we can attempt to find an edge or bottom body for shadow work. For those into digging and digging to find the ultimate primordial “thing” or No-Thing, The Void or Abyss might eventually rear her head. This territory has been seen as the most terrifying place in existence, possibly even more so than the Spanish Inquisition. It has even been known as Enlightnment’s Evil Twin.
Yet, this attitude of fear is only adopted by those who resist this space/ma. The sign before the entrance to Dante’s Inferno read “Abandon hope all ye who enter here.” But the key is in interpretation. Abandon hope by surrendering, else resistance will be the true hell.
For those who have reached this edge of all edges, they may have in result gotten to step into the kingdom of kingdoms, The Void’s “opposite” associated with maximum meaning and value. This happens because The Void may imply its opposite. If The Void is the serpent’s ferocious mouth (the end of everything) then its opposite is the beginning of everything—the Tail or Tale (story/Jo-Ha-Kyu). Life is a story, a theater. For this reason, shadowbody butoh is about life resonance.
When we dance butoh, we dance life. If we go to The Void, it’s in order to kiss the immortal flower that grows from it. It may be one entity, the ouroboros.
World of Abyss — Hijikata’s abyss qualia butoh-fu.
The ouroboros may be the ma of mas. The ouroboros is the serpent that bites its own tail. This shows a prolific, powerful image of primordial nature, lying at the heart of all that we are and do. All appears to possess a type of feedback loop. This can be visualized by pondering over the notion of memory with its endless loopy associations of past, which are but endless copies fed into itself. One cannot say that the past or future exist identically as the present, unless one steps radically inward or outward to visualize a notion of transcending space/time itself, hence theoretically making all exist equally to each other. Yet, who can ever say this is also not space/ma?
For a century, Quantum Physics attempted to dive into smaller and smaller bits of substance, attempting to find the most primordial substance of all, only to find itself biting its own tail like the ouroboros. They noticed the act of observation completely modified or undermined their own experiments. This appears to make the primordial more mysterious than it was in the first place.
Related butoh psychodrama: Ouroboros
“‘Time’ is expressed in Japanese as ‘space in flow,’ making time a dimension of space.” – Gunther Nitschke5
Time comes from space. This manual breaks time into two types, artificial and natural.
Artificial time is the time of the modern world and bears a duplicity illusion. My conjecture is that nothing can be precisely duplicated. Even Aristotle’s Law of Noncontradiction principle of A = A may not take into account time. The first A and the second A exist in different space-times. Though Aristotle may be referring to the original A, there may be something lost in the process. So artificial time has the following characteristics: (1) Illusion; (2) Rhythm; (3) Meter; (4) Lag.
Natural time or butoh time on the other hand has no rhythm. Think of the flight of a butterfly. Does the butterfly dance in a specific time like a ballet dancer? Is the butterfly counting? Butoh time has the following characteristics: (1) Lack of rhythm; (2) Nowness; (3) Immediacy; (4) Newness; (5) Chaos.
Tatsumi Hijikata speaks of this natural time in a line of his butoh-fu World of Flowers: “Dancing a flower show us the joys of changes in time and space.”13
Even though I have classified here two different times, at the end of the day, I feel there is always only one time, and that is Butoh Time. The so-called artificial time just appears to not be in harmony with nature, but is automatically in harmony with nature. We may just not be able to see it. If anybody were to zoom into any rhythm (e.g. a heart rhythm), one would find that there is not one identical wave function. Butoh just blows up this concept to make it more obvious.
We must also develop what we feel is our best use of timing. Tame is a Japanese term that means to wait for the best timing for a particular movement. For instance, Rhizome Lee uses the reference of “a shout and a girl – shivering before collapsing,” which is a line in Tatsumi Hijikata’s Quiet House. Lee explains that there is a particular timing when the shivering gets to such a point (an inner shout) where the collapse is in full resonance.10
Exercise: Decresendo/Cresendo in Space
This exercise is inspired by Julie Becton Gillum. From one end of the space, you either begin quickly and decresendo to near-stillness or begin in near-stillness and cresendo to quick.
The length of time in a performance is broken up into 3 from the performance theorist Richard Schechner: (1) Event time; (2) Set time; (3) Symbolic time. Butoh can play around with any of these.
Event time, when the activity itself has a set sequence and all the steps of that sequence must be completed no matter how long (or short) the elapsed clock time. Examples: baseball, racing, hopscotch; rituals where a “response” or a “state” is sought, such as rain dances, shamanic cures, revival meetings; scripted theatrical performances taken as a whole.
Set time, where an arbitrary time pattern is imposed on events—they begin and end at certain moments whether or not they have been “completed.” Here there is an agonistic contest between the activity and the clock. Examples: football, basketball, games structured on “how many” or “how much” can you do in x time. (shadowbody note: It is encouraged to internalize the set time via one’s internal clock. I call this honoring Father Saturn since Saturn in mythology is Father Time.)
Symbolic time, when the span of the activity represents another (longer or shorter) span of clock time. Or where time is considered differently, as in Christian notions of “the end of time,” the Aborigine “dreamtime,” or Zen’s goal of the “ever present.” Examples: theater, rituals that reactualize events or abolish time, make- believe play and games.14
To Akira Kasai, butoh would most certainly fall into symbolic time, or what he calls body time. He notes, “When the dancer transitions from ‘social time’ to the slower ‘body time’, s/he allows passive perception to direct movement, allowing stimuli to ‘call’ him or her in ways that most of us fail to hear and then respond to.”17
In performance art, anything that focuses on a long passage of time (such as 3 hours or more) is called a durational piece.15